Dying words could be lies: SC

By: admin | Last Updated: Thursday, 20 March 2014 8:19 AM
0

Total Shares

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has acquitted four members of a family of murder after taking the view that the deceased falsely implicated her in-laws of setting her ablaze.

 

The court said a dying declaration was usually relied upon, but in this case the deceased appeared to have named — for “inexplicable reasons” — six members of her in-laws’ family.

 

“It is true that when a person is on his or her death bed, there is no reason to state a falsehood but it is equally true that it is not possible to delve into the mind of a person who is facing death,” the court said.

 

“In the present case, the death of Asha Devi and the circumstances in which she died are extremely unfortunate but at the same time it does appear that for some inexplicable reason she put the blame for her death on all her in-laws without exception.”

 

A bench of Justices Ranjana Prakash Desai and Madan B. Lokur passed the recent judgment while acquitting four members of the family convicted for the murder of Asha Devi in Haryana’s Jagdhari district in April 1996. Two members have died.

 

Both the trial court and Punjab and Haryana High Court had convicted the six.

 

However, the apex court noted that there was enough material to prove that two of them — a brother-in-law and his wife — were residing in Haryana’s Pinjore at the time of the murder based on the man’s office attendance records. It then decided to give the other two surviving persons the benefit of doubt and acquit them.

First Published: Thursday, 20 March 2014 8:19 AM

Related Stories

Gopi bahu turns bride!
Gopi bahu turns bride!

Gopi bahu turns bride! For latest breaking news, other top stories log on to: http://www.abplive.in

6.8 magnitude quake hits West Bengal, Bihar & Jharkhand, epicentre in Myanmar
6.8 magnitude quake hits West Bengal, Bihar & Jharkhand, epicentre in Myanmar

6.8 magnitude quake hits West Bengal, Bihar & Jharkhand, epicentre in Myanmar. Tremors

Kaurwaki slaps Samrat Ashok publicly, watch full episode of Saas Bahu Aur Saazish
Kaurwaki slaps Samrat Ashok publicly, watch full episode of Saas Bahu Aur Saazish

Kaurwaki slaps Samrat Ashok publicly, watch full episode of Saas Bahu Aur Saazish. For latest

Rumoured couple Shaheer-Erica open up on their Indonesia vacation
Rumoured couple Shaheer-Erica open up on their Indonesia vacation

Rumoured couple Shaheer-Erica open up on their Indonesia vacation. For latest breaking news, other

Know everything about Surrogacy Bill
Know everything about Surrogacy Bill

New Delhi:  Salient features of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016, cleared by the Union cabinet on Wednesday: Who

Delhi assembly ratifies GST bill
Delhi assembly ratifies GST bill

New Delhi: The Delhi assembly on Wednesday ratified the Goods and Services Tax bill with Deputy Chief Minister Manish

Bulandshahr gang-rape accused plead innocence, seek narco test
Bulandshahr gang-rape accused plead innocence, seek narco test

Lucknow:  The four accused in the Bulandshahr gang-rape case on Wednesday pleaded not guilty in a Bulandshahr court

Leaked Scorpene papers won't affect stealth and operational capabilities: Indian Navy
Leaked Scorpene papers won't affect stealth and operational capabilities: Indian Navy

New Delhi: The Indian Navy said on Wednesday the leaked documents on the Scorpene submarine not impact its stealth and

No political appointments in pollution control boards: NGT
No political appointments in pollution control boards: NGT

New Delhi: The National Green Tribunal (NGT) on Wednesday directed all the states and union territories to review the

Militant attack in Pulwama, 9 security personnel injured
Militant attack in Pulwama, 9 security personnel injured

Srinagar: At least nine security personnel, including a Deputy Superintendent of Police, were injured today in a

scorecard

ABP Live Newsletters